CMM COMPASS
CMM COMPASS Choose by Features Comparison of Zeiss CMMs and Tokyo Seimitsu CMMs

Comparison of Zeiss CMMs and Tokyo Seimitsu CMMs

Contents.

Coordinate Measuring Machines (CMMs) are essential tools in precision manufacturing, supporting quality assurance and high-accuracy inspections. Among the leading players in this space, Zeiss and Tokyo Seimitsu both offer robust solutions that serve advanced industrial needs. Rather than ranking one above the other, this article focuses on exploring their unique characteristics, specifications, and intended applications.

Zeiss

Features of Zeiss CMMs

CMM 'ZEISS PRISMO (Carl Zeiss)' image
Source: Zeiss website (https://www.zeiss.co.jp/metrology/seihin/shisutemu/zahyo-sokuteiki/mon-ido-katachi-zahyo-sokuteiki/prismo.html)

Zeiss is a global leader in metrology, known for delivering precision instruments used in sectors like aerospace, automotive, and healthcare. Zeiss CMMs are available in a variety of configurations including bridge, gantry, and horizontal-arm types. Their design emphasizes stability, repeatability, and adaptability across various inspection tasks.

One of Zeiss's key strengths is sensor flexibility. The company supports a modular system that enables switching between tactile, optical, and even X-ray (CT) sensors. This allows users to tailor the system for specific tasks, enhancing utility across multiple production lines.

The CALYPSO software is another highlight. It offers CAD integration, parametric inspection plans, and automated measurement strategies. Although the software requires training, it unlocks significant efficiencies once mastered.

Specifications of Zeiss CMMs

Below is a summary of two representative models:

Model Measurement Range Accuracy Key Features
CONTURA X: 700–1200 mm, Y: 700–2400 mm, Z: 600–1000 mm 1.4 + L/350 µm Bridge-type, multiple probe options, flexible software
PRISMO Ultra Various configurations 0.5 µm + L/500 Ultra-high precision, air bearings, damped granite bed

Tokyo Seimitsu

Features of Tokyo Seimitsu CMMs

ZEISS XENOS
Source: Tokyo Seimitsu (https://www.accretech.com/jp/product/measuring/system/cmm/zeiss_xenos.html)

Tokyo Seimitsu, operating under the ACCRETECH brand, is known for its precision engineering in the measurement domain. In collaboration with Zeiss since 1995, Tokyo Seimitsu markets a range of co-developed CMM systems that combine Zeiss's optical expertise with Tokyo Seimitsu's precision hardware manufacturing.

These CMMs are engineered for accuracy and environmental stability. Many systems include air bearings, thermal compensation structures, and vibration isolation. Tokyo Seimitsu models also leverage Zeiss's CALYPSO software, ensuring high interoperability and advanced analytics.

ZEISS PRISMO
Source: Tokyo Seimitsu (https://www.accretech.com/jp/product/measuring/system/cmm/zeiss_prismo.html)

Specifications of Tokyo Seimitsu CMMs

Here are two representative models available through Tokyo Seimitsu and Zeiss:

Model Measurement Range Accuracy Special Features
ZEISS XENOS 850 x 1200 x 1000 mm ±0.3 μm Ultra-high precision, advanced air bearings, active vibration isolation
ZEISS PRISMO 700 mm to 3000 mm (configurable) ±0.9 μm High-speed scanning, multi-sensor compatibility, temperature compensation

Comparison Between Zeiss and Tokyo Seimitsu

Both companies deliver top-tier CMM solutions, but there are nuanced differences in focus and application. Zeiss maintains global control over design, software, and sensor systems, ensuring standardization and a broader international support network. Tokyo Seimitsu, in contrast, customizes systems more toward Japanese industrial standards and offers enhanced support within the domestic market.

Tokyo Seimitsu models, while co-developed with Zeiss, often focus more on high-precision applications and include features fine-tuned for localized needs. Zeiss offers a more expansive portfolio including CT metrology and inline automation solutions.

Software-wise, both leverage CALYPSO, maintaining consistency in data processing and workflow management. However, Zeiss often supports newer software versions and broader plug-in ecosystems more quickly across global markets.

Ideal Users for Each Brand

Zeiss is ideal for multinational corporations and R&D-heavy sectors requiring ultra-high precision and broad sensor options. Its global footprint ensures reliable support for operations across borders.

Tokyo Seimitsu is well-suited for manufacturers within Japan or East Asia who need localized support, Japanese-language documentation, and extremely tight tolerances in stable production environments. Their equipment is optimized for high-throughput, shop-floor integration with Japanese quality management systems.

Conclusion

Zeiss and Tokyo Seimitsu provide world-class metrology systems suited to a range of advanced inspection needs. While Zeiss emphasizes global scalability, sensor versatility, and high-end automation, Tokyo Seimitsu excels in locally optimized precision and tailored support. Choosing between them depends on your operational scale, geographic location, and specific technical requirements.

   

Top 3 Recommendations for CMM
by Application

For Ease of Use
and Versatility
XM Series(KEYENCE)

Source: KEYENCE Website(https://www.keyence.com/products/measure-sys/cmm/xm/index_pr.jsp)

This CMM has a caliper-like feel, enabling even beginners to perform high-precision measurements. It can be carried without the need for temperature control, allowing for immediate measurements at any desired location and time. As it doesn't require a large installation space, it's a CMM with a low entry barrier.

  • A unique handheld-type CMM that can be used with a caliper-like feel
  • Usable outside of the measurement room
  • Wide measurement range of up to 2m
KEYENCE Website Read More
For Measurement Accuracy
and Stability
ZEISS XENOS(Carl Zeiss)

Source: Carl Zeiss Website(https://www.zeiss.com/metrology/products/systems/cmm.html)

Utilizing linear drive on all axes, this CMM boasts high precision with a maximum permissible length measurement error of 0.3+L/1000μm, repeatability of ±0.2μm, and resolution of 0.001μm. The reduced occurrence of errors allows for a decrease in the need for remeasurement.

  • Maximum permissible length measurement error of 0.3+L/1000μm
  • Repeatability of ±0.2μm
  • Resolution of 0.001μm
Carl Zeiss Website Read More
For Smart Factory
Integration
CRYSTA-Apex(Mitutoyo)

Source: Mitutoyo Website(https://www.mitutoyo.com/products/coordinate-measuring-machines/)

A CNC CMM that was first developed in 1976.

It features applications that respond to the demand for "Smart Factories" by allowing monitoring of operational status and maintenance management of the machine through the network.

  • Developed by drawing on over 80 years of manufacturing expertise
  • Selection of optimal probe for the workpiece
  • Compatible with Smart Factory environments
Mitutoyo Website Read More

Reasons for Selection

  • Ease of Use and Versatility: Based on our research, these CMMs offers the highest precision and a wide measurement range among handheld devices usable outside the measurement room.
  • Measurement Accuracy and Stability: Among the surveyed options, these CMMs exhibit the highest values in terms of maximum allowable length measurement error, repeatability, and resolution.
  • Smart Factory Integration: Among the surveyed manufacturers, these CMMs are most extensively implemented as CNC CMM compatible with S.M.S. (SMART Measurement System).